After a few days living with a Microsoft Band…

I have worn a Polar s610 heart rate monitor as my watch for years (probably 15+), as I write it needs another battery swap, which means sending it to Polar, something I have done a couple of times in the past for servicing The batteries in the watch last 5 years or so, in the associated heart rate monitor strap maybe a bit more depending on usage.

The point is I am used to having a device that ‘can’ give heart rate information, it seems normal, but I do need to remember to put on the heart rate strap, something I would only usually do for a race or specific training set. Now don’t get me wrong having the s610 does not mean I am a talented athlete, but I do have good idea of my heart rate for any given sporting activity

So this week I got hold of a Microsoft Band, nice timing as my s610 needs that new battery, but how has the Band done?

Microsoft Band in Watch Mode

Whilst in the USA last year I had tried on other people’s Bands and felt them cumbersome, but mine is a small (previously I had only tried on large or mediums). Actually I find it little worse on the wrist than the s610. So tip here – it seems sizing is critical, especially if have spindly little wrists like me. Like compression sport wear, if in doubt err to a smaller size.

Beyond being a watch, I have been using it to track my runs and cycling and the HR seems accurate, at least the numbers are within a few beats of what I would expect on the s610, and it is so much easier than remembering the monitor strap for my Polar. It is great that it gets so much information so easily, and that it  can push it onto other services as I want without me having to play with modem style audio based Polar SonicLink (I did say my s610 is old)

But of course I do have some issues:

  • The obvious one is battery life. I am seeing 6 to 48 hours depending on how much GPS I used. For the first two days it was great, when I used it as a watch, no charging needed. However, yesterday I did a a 5K Parkrun and a 40K bike ride, so after less than 3 hours of GPS, HR and screen on etc. it needed a charge. I can live with this I think, I do need to make sure the screen is off and see how that helps. I don’t want it dying on a half day or so cycle ride.
  • Turns out I glance at my watch a lot – as by default the screen is off I have to press button to see the time – it took me back to the LED watches of the 70s. Again this comes back to battery life. I know I can leave the screen on, but it just needs to much power.
  • When running the splits are in km, it would be nice to have my own trigger e.g laps.  For example on my local Parkrun we do 3 laps, and I know my target splits. On the Polar I have a big red button to press for each lap to get a lap time,  on the Band I have to do maths in my head. Now there might be a way to do this, but I have not found it yet.
  • Finally my major issue is it is not waterproof so can’t wear it to swim, so not useful in a Triathlon as it is as something else to have to put on in T1. Also I do use the time splits in the pool on my S610 when training, again counting laps not KM (I don’t swim that far!). Not sure how they would make it fully waterproof, but it would be a great feature.

So first thoughts, loads better than I expected, all my niggles are minors and are more to do with current battery technology than the device itself. For the price, £169 at Amazon UK for pre-order, an interesting alternative to Garmin or Polar. Certainly got some interest at the 10K race I did this morning.

4 Replies to “After a few days living with a Microsoft Band…”

  1. There is a watch mode in setting and click on the clock and then click on watch mode. It will show time and the date with out having a notice impact to battery. Having the screen on always doing a run / bike ride will eat the battery up . With out it you should see 5 to 6 hours of gps if the screen is not on the whole time.

  2. Ok, 4 hour ride today, Band battery at about 40% when I got back. Had the screen off the whole ride, just got the km notification. I can live with that. I will give watch mode more of a try too

  3. Update – I am too used to a waterproof watch. Too many close calls with the band and water!

  4. I have noticed that you really need to let it charge to 100%. Today I only let it charge to 60% (20 min or so) and only got about 6 hours (45 min of which was using GPS). Seems the % on charge is a poor indicator, as it gets to 60% fast, then crawls to 80% and then 100%

Comments are closed.